Auston Matthews: Should He Stay Or Should He Go? – opinion

TORONTO, June 20, 2023 – Coffey, Messier and Fuhr. Ah, those were the days before the NHL’s creation of the salary cap, which seeks to level the playing field, ensuring even the Florida Panthers and Las Vegas Golden Knights could vie for Lord Stanley’s Cup.

In the realm of NHL greatness, few names shine as brightly as Auston Matthews. With a collection of accolades including the esteemed Hart Trophy and Art Ross, he has etched his name in the annals of hockey history. Notably, he joins the exclusive ranks of NHL players who have surpassed the remarkable milestone of 60 goals in a single season. Much like the magnificent Toronto skyline, the towering CN Tower, and the bustling Union Station, Matthews embodies the essence of this vibrant city. He personifies the very ingredient that defines Toronto.

As the face of the franchise, Matthews has garnered immense popularity, making him one of the most beloved figures to grace the NHL. With his deadly unrivalled wrist shot, he captivates audiences and leaves fans in awe. Toronto and Matthews are intrinsically connected, their destinies intertwined in a fascinating ice dance. Adored by fans and despised by foes, he evokes strong emotions from all corners of the hockey world.

However, the 2023 season marked a turning point for Matthews and his team. After six years of playoff disappointments, the Maple Leafs finally progressed to the gruelling second round against the eight seed Florida Panthers. Yet, what seemed like a triumphant moment for the city soon turned into another bitter postseason defeat for the blue and white. Fans are now demanding change, hungry for a different outcome.

Undoubtedly, the Maple Leafs boast an abundance of talent. With the gifted playmaker Mitch Marner, the electrifying William Nylander, and the seasoned leadership of Captain John Tavares, the team possesses an arsenal of high profile stars. Each player has the ability to ignite the crowd, dazzling spectators with moves reminiscent of the Harlem Globetrotters’ finest moments. At times, this maligned forward group resembles the high octane offense of the Edmonton Oilers from the eighties, led by legends such as Gretzky, Kurri, Messier, Tikkanen, and then some.

Firing Dubas

Amidst the aftermath of President Brendan Shanahan’s controversial decision to dismiss General Manager Kyle Dubas and the subsequent appointment of Brad Treliving as the new GM, the Toronto Maple Leafs find themselves in a precarious situation. With just one year left on his contract, Auston Matthews will soon possess an exhaustive no-trade list, which comes into effect on July 1. As the situation unfolds, the key question emerges, does Matthews desire to remain in the hockey crazed metropolis of Toronto, where his every move garners front page headlines or finds its way onto sports tickers across all channels.

However, before passing judgment on Matthews future and his relationship with both Toronto and the Maple Leafs, it’s imperative to delve into his past.

Auston’s Remarkable Journey

Born on September 17, 1997, in San Ramon, California, Auston Matthews defied the conventional path to NHL stardom. Raised in Scottsdale, Arizona, a location far from traditional hockey hotbeds, Matthews embarked on a unique route to the professional ranks. Rather than opting for the well trodden paths of the Canadian Hockey League (CHL) or the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), Matthews took his talents to the ZSC Lions in Switzerland’s National League A.

Playing against seasoned professionals in Switzerland provided Matthews with invaluable experience and honed his skills for the highest level of competition. This atypical path allowed him to seamlessly transition to the NHL, showcasing his exceptional talent and proving that talent knows no boundaries.

Matthews’ time in Switzerland also exposed him to the rich tapestry of European hockey culture. The diverse styles and approaches prevalent in European hockey have undoubtedly influenced his playing style, adding a unique flavor to his game that sets him apart from other NHL stars.

Throughout his journey, Matthews has acknowledged the significant role played by his family in his success, with his mother Ema holding a special place in his heart. Ema’s unwavering support and dedication were evident as she spent countless hours driving her son to practices and games while nurturing his passion for the sport. Furthermore, Ema’s Mexican heritage has influenced Matthews perspective, allowing him to appreciate the importance of diversity in a predominantly white sport.

When Matthews achieved his first playoff series victory in 2023, Ema’s emotional reaction showcased her immense pride in her son’s accomplishments. Her presence and support have been vital elements of his journey to becoming an NHL superstar.

Matthews’ Future: A Crossroads for Toronto

The ongoing chatter surrounding Matthews suggests that he may be inclined to remain loyal to the Toronto Maple Leafs, committing to a groundbreaking three to five year contract. If such a deal were to materialize, Matthews would undoubtedly become the highest paid player in NHL history. While this would demonstrate his immediate dedication to the Leafs’ pursuit of the coveted Stanley Cup, it also raises the prospect that, should things not go according to plan in the coming years, he could depart from the city akin to a Kawhi Leonard-esque departure.

In such a scenario, Matthews might opt to sign with his hometown Arizona Coyotes, and bring him closer to his mother. The future awaits Matthews, and his decision will undoubtedly shape not only his own career but also the course of the Leafs and the city of Toronto. Will he forge a lasting legacy with the Maple Leafs or potentially venture elsewhere, leaving behind a wave of uncertainty and what-ifs?

Considering a Trade: Exploring New Paths for the Leafs

Let’s confront the hard reality on the ice. Matthew Tkachuk played his final game of the Stanley Cup final with a broken sternum. Most individuals would struggle to even move, let alone score a game tying goal with less than three minutes remaining. While Matthews is undeniably an exceptional player, often hailed as a messianic leader akin to Jesus walking on water, it’s worth noting that he rarely engages in physicality. Although his coach claims he leads by example, one may question the validity of that assertion.

Brett Hull, for instance, showcased remarkable goal-scoring abilities but failed to win a championship in St. Louis. In hockey history, we’ve witnessed the Edmonton Oilers triumph without Wayne Gretzky, primarily due to the remarkable leadership of Mark Messier, a true titan in the realm of team sports.

Messier embodied the spirit of Gordie Howe, excelling in scoring, fighting, checking, and, most importantly, winning at all costs. Remember when he boldly guaranteed victory over the New Jersey Devils during the year the New York Rangers claimed their first Cup since 1940?. If the Toronto Maple Leafs aspire to clinch their first Stanley Cup since 1967, it seems evident that they require a leader both on and off the ice.

Regrettably, so far Matthews hasn’t quite fit that bill, but there are players out there who could complement the Leafs’ core and guide them to the promised land.

Here are a few potential trade targets to consider:

• Nathan MacKinnon: He single-handedly elevated the Colorado Avalanche from last place to Cup champions, showcasing remarkable skill even with an average goaltender. Although it’s highly unlikely Colorado would part with him
• Brady Tkachuk: If the Senators are willing to part with a couple of high draft picks, Tkachuk’s grit and physicality could bolster the Leafs lineup and potentially lead them to triumph in the coming years.
• Pierre-Luc Dubois: As a formidable grinding centre, Dubois could be an enticing addition to the Leafs, especially if they can also secure Hellebuyck in the deal. However, dealing Samsonov and other prospects might be necessary.
• Jack Eichel: Eichel is an elite center with exceptional offensive skills. He expressed frustration with the Buffalo Sabres’ situation, but once in Vegas won a cup in his second season.
• Aleksander Barkov: The captain of the Florida Panthers, Barkov is an outstanding two-way center with exceptional defensive prowess. His offensive abilities and leadership qualities would make him an attractive target for the Leafs.
• Brayden Point: Point has emerged as a key contributor for the Tampa Bay Lightning, showcasing his scoring ability and clutch performances in the playoffs. His versatility and ability to step up in crucial moments could make him an intriguing trade target for Toronto
• Clayton Keller: Keller is a skilled forward for the Arizona Coyotes. He has shown promise as a playmaker and has the potential to develop into a top offensive threat. Included in the Kellar package the Leafs would also want to obtain Christian Dvorak: Dvorak is a centre who has displayed consistency and offensive ability for the Coyotes. He has a good hockey IQ and is capable of contributing offensively. Dvorak could be an interesting piece in a potential trade. As well, the Coyotes will need to throw in a prospect like Barrett Hayton: Hayton is a highly regarded prospect for the Coyotes. He was selected fifth overall in the 2018 NHL Entry Draft and has shown promise as a two-way centre. Including Hayton in a trade package would provide the Maple Leafs with a young player with significant potential.
• Cale Makar: He won the Cup with the Avalanche in 2033, winning the Conn Smythe Trophy as the most valuable player in the 2022 playoffs. He has been widely cited as one of the best defencemen and best players in the modern NHL.
• Elias Pettersson: Pettersson is a dynamic young centre for the Vancouver Canucks. Although he has had some injury issues, he has shown tremendous skill and potential. Including Pettersson in a trade package could be enticing for the Maple Leafs.
• Andrei Svechnikov: Svechnikov is a promising young winger for the Carolina Hurricanes. He has a great combination of size, skill, and scoring ability. Including Svechnikov in a trade package could add a scoring threat to the Maple Leafs’ lineup.
• Filip Forsberg: Forsberg is a talented forward for the Nashville Predators. He consistently puts up solid offensive numbers and has proven to be a reliable scorer. Adding Forsberg to a trade package could provide the Maple Leafs with additional scoring depth.
• Brad Marchand: Marchand is a versatile forward for the Boston Bruins. He is a consistent scorer and an agitator on the ice. Marchand’s offensive production and tenacity would be valuable for the Maple Leafs. However I doubt Boston and Toronto would engage (in fact it would be shocking) in any kind of trade being division rivals.
• Mark Stone: Stone is a talented winger who recently hoisted the Stanley Cup for the Vegas Golden Knights. He is known for his strong two-way play and ability to create scoring chances. Stone’s defensive abilities combined with his offensive skills would be an asset for the Maple Leafs.
• And last and perhaps the player that has the best chance of helping the Leafs win it all is – Leon Draisaitl: He is a highly skilled forward for the Edmonton Oilers. He has excellent offensive capabilities, including playmaking and goal-scoring ability. He’s a leader and every night plays like the game is on the line. At playoff time he becomes a warrior like few have ever seen.

Even if Leafs’ management can convince Matthews to sign a long term contract, he’s not going to turn into Messier anytime soon.

Auston is a stellar regular season player and may one day even score 80 goals but this writer sees you as one of the pieces needed to win a Cup but not the ‘key’ piece.

by Myles Shane

Other articles from totimes.ca – otttimes.ca – mtltimes.ca