These days, it’s rare to visit a Toronto spot that doesn’t have a burger on the menu. Many treat it as an afterthought, seeing it as an easy staple to please the masses.
It’s not. A truly delicious burger is not as common as you might expect.
It takes quality meat, the perfect bun, the right blend of toppings and sauces, and of course, the right price point.
We dissected the market, covering the spectrum from the rapid, high-volume $8 smash hit to the $33 ethically-sourced bistro staple. The evaluation here is based on repeatable excellence. If you’re a skeptical eater, this is your definitive roadmap.
Toronto’s Burger Hierarchy: The 13 Mandatory Stops
Toronto has some serious range when it comes to burgers. No matter your preference (smash or gourmet, classic or innovative), there’s a spot doing it at the highest level.
1. Aloette
Signature Dish: The Aloette Burger. Seared 6oz patty topped with aggressive Beaufort cheese and pickled onions.
Vibe Check: Elevated Bistro Diner. Snug booths and counter stools; Michelin-recognized and polished service in a space no wider than a train car.
Address: 163 Spadina Ave and 81 Bay St
Why It Made the Cut: It’s a debate piece on a bun. The assertive nature of the Beaufort cheese has polarized critics. Some find it too dominating, while others see it as the required element of complexity. It is technically flawless, forcing a conversation about boldness over blended subtlety.
2. Burger Drops
Signature Dish: Double American Burger / Oklahoma Style. Aggressively smashed for maximum crust; specifically lauded for the Oklahoma preparation where thinly sliced onions are pressed directly into the beef, caramelizing against the patty.
Vibe Check: Technical Takeout Institution. High-volume, hyper-focused, and highly praised, with limited seating available.
Address: 116 Atlantic Ave
Why It Made the Cut: Technical excellence. They achieve the necessary crust-to-bun ratio and master the Oklahoma technique, yielding an exceptional, signature integrated flavour defined by the intensive griddled onion caramelization
3. Richmond Station
Signature Dish: The Stn. Burger. Pasture-raised beef, aged cheddar, garlic aioli, and essential beet chutney. Served with rosemary fries.
Vibe Check: Bustling Neighbourhood Anchor. Relaxed professional hospitality, focused on ethical sourcing and high-quality staff.
Address: 1 Richmond St. W
Why It Made the Cut: The price is justified by philosophy and flavour. The chef-level complexity of the beet chutney provides a necessary sweet-earthy contrast that cuts the inherent fat of the pasture-raised beef, making this a master class in both composition and ethical commitment. They prove that burgers can be classy, even on date night.
4. Happy Burger
Signature Dish: Oklahoma Burger. Praised for superior patty seasoning, a great crust, and the impeccable layering of each bite.
Vibe Check: Focused Fast-Casual. High standard of execution delivered in a quick, reliable setting.
Address: Multiple locations
Why It Made the Cut: They win on distribution. A critical measure of a great burger is the simultaneous delivery of flavour and texture. Happy Burger nails the internal structure, guaranteeing an integrated, intense experience every time.
5. Rudy
Signature Dish: The Rudy (Double Cheeseburger). Reliable, minimalist, griddle-seared beef with standard fixings.
Vibe Check: Compact, No-Frills Anchor. Known for efficiency and reliability in high-traffic, late-night areas; limited seating.
Address: Multiple locations
Why It Made the Cut: The ultimate baseline of consistency. Maintaining a perfect crust and juicy interior across thousands of orders daily requires immense operational mastery. This reliability makes Rudy a staple in the volatile smash market.
6. Matty’s Patty’s Burger Club
Signature Dish: Cheeseburger. Defined by the juicy, tender patty and the signature Matty’s Patty’s sauce, praised for its mouth-watering flavour profile.
Vibe Check: Chef-Driven Takeout Club. High energy and popular status driven by celebrity chef Matty Matheson’s reputation.
Address: 923 Queen Street W
Why It Made the Cut: The sauce is the celebrity. The house specialty sauce is the critical binding agent that elevates this standard cheeseburger to a benchmark for flavour blending and sheer deliciousness.
7. The Senator
Signature Dish: Classic Senator Cheeseburger. A thick, classic patty made from locally sourced, quality ingredients.
Vibe Check: Historic, Time-Warp Diner. Authentic 1920s architecture with an open kitchen, maintaining a tradition of serving hearty food.
Address: 249 Victoria St
Why It Made the Cut: This is the history lesson. Before the smash burger dominated, The Senator set the benchmark for quality, simple diner food. It serves a menu rooted in classics, modernized through high-quality local sourcing, including honey from their organic Caledon farm and ingredients from more than a dozen local purveyors.
8. JABS (Just Another Burger Spot)
Signature Dish: Double Patty Oklahoma Burger. Specifically noted for its extreme juiciness and super gooey cheese melt.
Vibe Check: Emerging Contender. A spot focused on winning the quality-to-price ratio war, offering high-quality at competitive price points against established kings.
Address: 630 St Clair Ave W
Why It Made the Cut: A testament to execution, JABS managed to impress seasoned critics with superior moisture retention and an exceptional, satisfying cheese pull. Their success demonstrates that even in a crowded market, technical mastery of juiciness can still define a new champion.
9. Bindi’s Burgers
Signature Dish: Indian-Inspired Smashburger. Halal lamb and beef patties topped with tomato chutney, spiced aioli, mint, and cilantro. Customers are encouraged to pair this with deep-fried paneer.
Vibe Check: Hidden Tavern Pop-Up. Located upstairs, demanding an insider’s navigation and rewarding those who seek it out.
Address: 12 Clinton St
Why It Made the Cut: True culinary fusion done right. It takes the perfected smash technique and explodes the flavour profile with aggressive, sweet-spicy Indian influences. This is mandatory for those tired of the traditional American flavour profile.
10. Cabano’s Cheeseburgers
Signature Dish: Cabano Cheeseburger. Focused on delivering high-quality, dependable comfort food results.
Vibe Check: Comfort Food Specialist. Straightforward and reliable, recognized for running value-enhancing deals.
Address: 75 St Nicholas St
Why It Made the Cut: The essential comfort player. In a market where many attempt to over-intellectualize, Cabano’s offers high-grade, guaranteed satisfaction that delivers flawlessly on the basic promise of the American cheeseburger.
11. Manita
Signature Dish: Manita Burger. Praised for its precise components and clean, high-grade beef flavour profile.
Vibe Check: Refined European Bistro. Sophisticated dining where the burger sits comfortably alongside a diverse, high-quality menu.
Address: Multiple locations
Why It Made the Cut: The standard bearer for restraint. In an environment often dominated by overwrought components, Manita’s success lies in its balanced composition, allowing the inherent quality of the beef and bun to carry the weight.
12. Holy Chuck Burgers
Signature Dish: The Holy Chuck. Two 4oz aged beef patties, maple smoked bacon, caramelized onions, cheese, and chuck sauce. The infamous “Go Chuck Yourself” (six patties, six cheese slices, and fixings) is the defining marker of their maximalist approach.
Vibe Check: Maximalist Diner. Indulgent, prioritizing volume and decadence.
Address: 1450 Yonge St
Why It Made the Cut: They are the benchmark for unapologetic gluttony. Their longevity is based on the quality of their aged beef patty and the sheer commitment to volume, appealing directly to those with a truly hearty appetite.
13. Harry’s Charbroiled
Signature Dish: Double Jane. A thin patty distinguished by its aggressive charbroiled searing technique, creating a smoky flavour. Noted for the quality of its briny pickles and the use of raw white onion.
Vibe Check: Classic Char Joint. Unfussy, specializing in the charbroil method, which offers a distinctly smokier profile.
Address: 255 Coxwell Ave
Why It Made the Cut: It’s the superior char. The charbroiled method, often resulting in dryness, is perfected here. The intensely focused heat yields maximum crust and juiciness, supported by high-quality, classic garnishes that provide essential acidity and texture.
Stop Scrolling, Start Eating
You have the precise coordinates for the best burgers in Toronto. Save this guide. Text it to your skeptical friend. Then, get off the couch and confirm the verdict yourself.
Burger Questions, Answered Without the BS
1. What is the real difference between a Smash Burger and a Gourmet Burger?
The distinction is based on technique and intention. A Smash Burger (e.g., Rudy, Burger Drops) uses thin patties pressed hard onto a hot griddle, prioritizing the Maillard reaction to achieve maximum crispy crust and speed. Gourmet Burgers (e.g., Aloette, Richmond Station) are typically thicker, often utilize premium or ethically sourced beef, and focus on complex, high-end toppings like beet chutney or aged specialty cheese. Smash is about rapid, technical efficiency; Gourmet is about culinary intention and complex composition.
2. How much should a great burger actually cost in Toronto?
The price is tied to the style and philosophy. Elite smash burgers should cost between $8 and $15 for a double. If you’re paying $20+ for a smash, you’re overpaying. Gourmet, chef-driven burgers command a premium, starting around $25 and climbing to $35, justified by ingredient provenance, chef status, and sit-down ambiance.
3. Where can I find a truly authentic, old-school diner burger experience?
For genuine nostalgia and classic charbroiled preparation that predates the smash trend, two spots define the era. The Senator, operating continuously since 1929, provides the historic downtown benchmark.
4. What are the mandatory side dishes?
Fries are a baseline, and you can’t go wrong. For a truly rich, juicy burger, look for contrast; crispy sides like high-quality onion rings or a mix of both fries and rings provide the essential crunch that balances the patty’s fat. If you’re exploring fusion, the pairing of Bindi’s Indian-inspired smash burger with deep-fried paneer is a necessary detour from tradition, offering aggressive flavour and texture.
Eat Like You Mean It
Toronto’s burger scene is viciously competitive, built on crust, sauce and intention. They may all be sandwiches, but few are as worthy of obsession as a great burger.
Shame yourself if you cross the city for a second-tier patty. We have given you the roster of champions across all essential categories. Use this guide to demand excellence from your calories.
Go find the best burgers in Toronto. You’ve been given the keys; now drive the plate.
Best Restaurants in Greektown | Best Korean Restaurants in Toronto | Best Restaurants in the Junction
You must be logged in to post a comment.