Fiduciary duty is simple in principle: someone managing your investments must act in your best interest. When they chase commissions, hide conflicts, or gamble with unsuitable products, that duty breaks. The results are steep losses, frozen accounts, and shattered plans.
If you suspect a breach, move with purpose. Document everything you can recall, and save statements, emails, and notes from calls. Here is how Ontario investors can protect claims, build leverage, and position for recovery.
- Get a targeted legal assessment
You need jurisdiction, facts, and timelines clarified. Book a call with a Toronto securities lawyer, and ask about breach elements, limitation periods, and evidence gaps. Bring statements, KYC forms, trade confirmations, advisor emails, and complaint records. Be sure to outline losses and key dates.
An assessment can map venues quickly, including court, OSC proceedings, IIROC or CIRO arbitration, or mediated resolution. You also learn costs, funding options, and early settlement paths. Clarity prevents missteps that weaken viable claims.
- Lock down evidence immediately
Download statements, trade tickets, and notes from your portal. Screenshot risk tolerance entries and product disclosures. Additionally, save prospectuses and offer supplements, and export email threads with your advisor, including read receipts. Keep a diary of calls and meetings with times, names, and promises.
In addition, ask the firm for your New Account Application Form and KYC updates. Request retention holds to ensure records are not deleted. Precision on dates, instructions, and suitability makes causation clear.
- Mitigate losses and open a formal complaint
Freeze discretionary trading authority if needed, and decline further unsuitable trades in writing. You should then file a complaint with the firm’s compliance office. Cite products, dates, and losses, and ask for the investigation protocol and response timeline.
Consider an OSC tip if misconduct is systemic. Be sure to also review insurer or fidelity bond coverage. If the margin was misused, demand interest relief. Make sure to keep your tone factual. You are building a record that regulators and courts will read.
- Frame liability and quantify damages
Breach of fiduciary duty often pairs with negligence, misrepresentation, and unsuitable recommendations. Your lawyer will test each element: duty, breach, causation, and damages. Ontario limitation periods can be short, and discoverability matters, so be sure to track when red flags surfaced.
Damages require careful math. Compare portfolio performance to a benchmark strategy. Add interest and lost opportunity, and consider tax impacts. If churning occurred, quantify excess commissions. If concentration caused losses, model a diversified alternative.
- Pick the right forum and settlement strategy
Choose the forum that fits your facts and goals. Some claims suit court litigation, and others move faster in dealer complaint programs, IIROC, CIRO arbitration, or private mediation. Weigh speed, discovery rights, and exposure.
Settlement leverage grows with a strong file. Consider demand letters with expert support. Expert suitability reports or forensic trading analyses can also help. Stay open to staged relief, including account credits, fee refunds, interest relief, and structured payments. The right venue and sequence can shorten the time to recovery.
Endnote
A breach of fiduciary duty cuts deeper than a market downturn, because it involves broken trust. Even so, you still have options. Protect your position by organizing documents, asking direct questions, and getting a focused legal review early. From there, you can choose the forum, pace, and strategy that fits your situation. Ontario law expects fair dealing from those who handle investor money. When that standard is not met, a clear, documented response is often the first step toward meaningful recovery.
Other articles from totimes.ca – otttimes.ca – mtltimes.ca