Skip to content
It’s hard to believe that just nine months ago, the Toronto Blue Jays were one strike away from a World Series title. On Monday, some of the pieces that got them there were gone — but this wasn’t a simple teardown. Over less than 48 hours, GM Ross Atkins ran five separate trades, and by the time the dust settled, Toronto had done as much buying as selling.
Toronto sits at 52-60 heading into deadline day, dead last in the AL East and 4 1/2 games back of a Wild Card spot (not insurmountable but a hill to climb nonetheless). And GM Ross Atkins didn’t wait for the 6 p.m. deadline to get moving; he was on the phone all weekend, and by Sunday night he’d already worked out two separate deals with the Cubs. But rather than simply stripping the roster for parts, Atkins used the churn to add two controllable, big-league-ready arms in José Soriano and Spencer Arrighetti — the kind of names a team stockpiles when it expects to be back in the race, not when it’s waving the white flag.
Our Beloved Gausman’s Gone — “Thank You Gausy”
The one that really stings: Kevin Gausman to Chicago for outfielder Brett Bateman and infielder Ty Southisene, a pair of low-level prospects. Gausman is 35 and in the last year of the five-year, $110 million deal he signed back in 2021, arguably the best free-agent contract this franchise has ever handed out. His numbers this year won’t blow anyone away — a losing record with a 4.38 ERA across 23 starts — but this is a guy who was part of the heartbeat of this city, bled blue and white and was the ace of Toronto’s pennant winner a year ago, building a career on a fastball-splitter combo that made him a nightmare for hitters for years.
Toronto is a pending free agent away from getting nothing for him this winter, so nobody’s really arguing the logic.
Gausman got the closest thing to a proper goodbye two days before the trade became official, in an MLB.com interview after what turned out to be his final start in a Blue Jays uniform. He didn’t want to speak in the past tense with the deal still unofficial, but he made clear how he felt about his five years in Toronto, saying it had been “the best decision I ever made… to come here.” Asked what he’d miss most, he pointed to the people around the organization rather than the city itself or the ballpark.
Manager John Schneider had already made his feelings known before the trade went through. After Toronto’s win over the Cardinals on Saturday, which was Gausman’s last start in a Blue Jays uniform, as it turned out, Schneider praised Gausman’s impact on the club during a Sportsnet broadcast segment, and in comments to MLB.com he called Gausman one of the best free-agent signings the franchise has ever made, describing him simply: “He’s a loyal dude. He wants to be part of what’s going on around him.” Designated hitter George Springer echoed that sentiment after the same game, telling Sportsnet’s Arden Zwelling how much Gausman meant to the clubhouse and how much the fans’ ovation for him meant to the dugout that day.
Emotional Farewell from Taylor Gausman
His wife, Taylor, posted her own emotional farewell to Instagram once the trade was official on Monday. She wrote about how quickly the last five years had gone by, how their kids had essentially grown up as Blue Jays fans, and how grateful the family felt for the time they’d spent in Toronto, calling the decision to sign there “the best decision we could have ever made.” She thanked the organization’s staff, the fans, and the other Blue Jays families who’d become like extended family over the years, closing the post by saying goodbye felt too hard, so it was “see you later” instead. By several accounts out of the clubhouse, the news hit hard once it became official — Daulton Varsho, who was dealt in a separate move the same day, told reporters the emotion of the last 24 hours had been overwhelming for the group, and that he’d felt it the night before as word reached Gausman.
The Blue Jays organization said its piece on the way out the door, posting on its official X account: “From the minute you became a Blue Jay, you embraced this city and this country as if it was your own. Thank you, Gausy, for all that you’ve meant to this team, to this community, to our clubhouse, and to this fanbase.”
Then the Blue Jays Went and Bought Something
Here’s the part that threw everyone: a team selling off its ace turned around and added pitching, too. Toronto grabbed right-hander Jameson Taillon off waivers from the same team, the Chicago Cubs, for cash considerations after Chicago cut him loose. It’s cheap and it’s a gamble: Taillon’s been rough this year, but he ran a much better ERA over 2024 and 2025, so the bet is that a new clubhouse fixes what Chicago couldn’t.
The bigger swing came a few hours later. “OFFICIAL: We’ve acquired RHP José Soriano from the Angels in exchange for INF Arjun Nimmala, OF Eddie Micheletti Jr. and RHP Angel Rivero,” the Blue Jays announced on their team account. Nimmala is a top-50 prospect in baseball, no small piece to give up. This one’s different from the Gausman trade in the way that matters most: Soriano isn’t a rental. He’s under club control through 2028. If the Blue Jays are serious about contending again in 2027, this is the kind of move that actually points that direction.
The Rest of the Ledger
Toronto also sent lefty Adam Macko to Texas for infielder/outfielder Josh Smith and right-hander Josh Stephan, the kind of housekeeping deal that happens around bigger news.
And the last domino everyone was waiting on finally fell: Daulton Varsho was traded to the Houston Astros for right-handed pitcher Spencer Arrighetti and cash considerations. It’s not the outfield return the Phillies rumors had suggested for over a week, but it’s a pitcher, and a controllable one — Arrighetti is only 26, though he’s currently on the injured list with foot nerve irritation, so Toronto won’t see anything from him right away. Varsho was already in the Astros’ lineup Monday, in the series opener against his old team.
The Blue Jays also moved reliever Jeff Hoffman as part of the deadline haul, closing out one of the more active sell-offs in franchise history.
Bieber remains the other pending free agent still drawing interest, though no deal had come together as of Monday. George Springer, who can veto any trade thanks to his 10-and-5 rights, made it pretty clear where he stands even before the deadline arrived. Asked about his no-trade rights by Sportsnet’s Ben Nicholson-Smith in the clubhouse over the weekend, Springer said: “I’m here. I love this team. I love this organization, and as far as I know, I’m here.”
GM Ross Atkins Believes the Jays Have a Shot
Atkins held a Monday evening call to walk through the moves, and he was blunt about the season while still framing the deadline as progress. “I think we’re close, but obviously, I would rather we were just adding at this point and making us a much better 26-man and 40-man roster,” Atkins said, with his team sitting 4 1/2 games out of the final AL Wild Card spot as play began Monday. He took the blame for a disappointing season a year removed from a World Series run, but said he still believes the club has a shot at the wild card over the final two months.
Who’s Paying For What
Gausman had roughly $7 million left on his deal, all of which is now Chicago’s problem. What Toronto got back for him, two minor leaguers still years from the majors, cost next to nothing in real dollars. The Taillon pickup was basically free, just cash considerations for a player nobody else wanted. Soriano’s the real financial commitment here: Toronto’s on the hook for his salary through 2028, and they paid for that certainty with a top-tier prospect in Nimmala.
Zoom out and the bigger number is this: once Springer, Varsho, Gausman and Bieber (if he’s moved) all come off the books this winter, Toronto clears a significant chunk of expiring money — cash the front office has made clear it wants to put back into the roster around Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
So Does Any of This Really Save the Season?
Not really, and nobody in the organization is pretending it does. At 52-60 with several teams to jump just to sniff a Wild Card spot, this season was already cooked before Gausman got on a plane to Chicago. What these moves are actually more about is next year: turning a veteran Gausman into two young players, locking down a controllable arm in Soriano, adding a controllable arm in Arrighetti for Varsho, and taking a flier on Taillon while the front office figures out whether Bieber and Springer are worth bringing back.
Blue Jays Could Face Gausman Right Away
It’s a strange feeling for the Toronto fans that watched this team fall one game short of a championship less than a year ago. Seeing Gausman in Cubs blue stings, no way around it, and Toronto might not even get much time to adjust: the two clubs are already scheduled to play each other Thursday at Wrigley Field, a makeup of a June rainout, which means Gausman could be on the mound against his former teammates before the week is out.
But if Soriano and Arrighetti turn into what Atkins is betting on, this deadline won’t be remembered as a white flag; it’ll be remembered as the moment Toronto started building the next version of this team.
lead photo by Hugo Coulbouée on Unsplash
You must be logged in to post a comment.